Football
- Trey Ferrin, class of 2017 – Bethel University
- Myles Stallings, class of 2017 – Bethel University
- Elijah Bervik, class of 2016 – Bethel University
- Drew Davis, class of 2015 – Bethel University
- Kyler Schmitt, class of 2015 – Dordt University
- Josiah LeDoux Hayes, class of 2014 – California Lutheran University
- Reese Ferrin, class of 2014 – Bethel University
- Greg Brock, class of 2012 – Taylor University
- Louis Cortez, class of 2010 – North Western College
- Ian Foster, class of 2010 – South Dakota Mines
- Cliff Planchard, class of 2008 – Tabor College
- Kyle Berry, class of 2007 – Sterling College
- Jordan Quinn, class of 2007 – Chadron State, then transferred to MidAmerica Nazarene University
- Trey Lewnard, class of 2004 – Bethany College
Soccer
- Grace Herring, class of 2017 – Covenant College
- Cass Chisholm, class of 2016 – George Fox University
- Jalissa DeHaan, class of 2015 – Dordt University
- Emily Losey, class of 2015 – Columbia International University
- Sarah Nyhoff, class of 2012 – Indiana Wesleyan University
- Kelsey Powell, class of 2012 – Indiana Wesleyan University
- Daniel Clark, class of 2010 – North Western College
- Carly Farrington, class of 2010 – North Western College
- Kara Quinn, class of 2010 – MidAmerica Nazarene University
- Tori Vasquez, class of 2010 – Dordt College
- Michela Fachathaler, class of 2008 – Colorado State University Pueblo
- Jessica Hommel, class of 2008 – Wheaton College
Baseball
- Drew Lloyd, class of 2018 – Colorado Christian University
- Cobi Jones, class of 2014 – Dordt University
- Karsten Leigvold, class of 2014 – Evangelical University
- Scott Wichael, class of 2013 – Evangelical University
- Taylor Bigandt, class of 2012 – Gustavus University and Concordia University
- Matthew Meek, class of 2011 – Dordt College
- John Ross, class of 2011 – unknown
- Brian Fast, class of 2010 – MidAmerica Nazarene University
- Michael Fast, class of 2010 – MidAmerica Nazarene University
- Mark Nyhoff, class of 2009 – Dordt College
- Greg Suryn, class of 2007 – Grinnell College
Volleyball
- Carissa Van Donselaar, class of 2017 – Calvin College
- Taya Hanna, class of 2014 – Clear Water Christian College
- Meredith Whatley, class of 2013 – Mesa State University
- Kendall Marine, class of 2009 – unknown
Basketball
- Katherine Oosthuizen, class of 2013 – Dordt University
- Vanessa Vigil, class of 2011 – Dordt College
- Joshua Sweeting, class of 2010 – Colorado Christian University
- Andrew Ulibarri, class of 2007 – North Western College
Cheer
- Catherine Baessler, class of 2011 – school unknown
- Emily Sloan, class of 2011 – school unknown
- Amanda Parker, class of 2008 – Azusa Pacific
Golf
- Ben Lanting, class of 2011 – Hope College
- Min Kyu Jeoon, class of 2010 – Colorado Christian University
Other Sports
- Adam Dawson, class of 2017 – Track and Field, Colorado State University
- Braidon McLean, class of 2015 – Lacrosse*, University of Arizona
- Alyssa Davis, class of 2013 – Hockey*, Liberty University
- Kyle Davis, class of 2012 – Hockey*, Liberty University
*These are not sports FRCS offered, so these students competed elsewhere during their high school years.